Quick Shelbyville KY MLS Search

Browse All Shelbyville KY Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

3 Beds 4 Baths 1658888 MLS
She's an absolute beauty! This jaw-dropper of a home on historic Magnolia Avenue is the perfect mix of historic details and modern touches! Nearly every inch of this home was renovated approximately 2 years ago! You'll find tons of gorgeous personal living space, loads of room for entertaining on the inside, a fire pit out back to gather with friends, plus a 2-bay detached garage with a second floor that could be used for anything your mind might dream up from extra storage to a craft room to a place to have band practice. The possibilities are endless! Speaking of possibilities, there are a few options to explore at 709 Magnolia Ave: Option 1- Make it your personal home! It's the kind of home that makes the front of a Hallmark card, one that just welcomes you to cozy up and stay a while. This street is the kind of place where you can see neighbors taking after-dinner strolls, walking their dogs, or learning to ride bikes. You're tucked in close to downtown and near great restaurants and shops plus just a few minutes from the bypass and interstate. It's the kind of place that just feels like home. Option 2: The current owners use the house for short-term rental and have had slam dunk success on Airbnb. Pick this up as part of your short-term rental portfolio or confidently enter the Airbnb world with a property with a proven track record. Complete furniture package negotiable. Either way -- home sweet home or Airbnb, don't miss the chance to see 709 Magnolia Ave. Join me Monday night from 5pm-7pm for an evening Open House or schedule your private showing.

709 Magnolia Ave, Shelbyville

4 Beds 3 Baths 1654651 MLS
It doesn't get much better than this!! 4 BEDROOM +3 FULL bathrooms on a CORNER LOT on sought-after Brown Avenue! It's hard to know where your eyes should land first! The stand out finishes? The moody, rich paint colors? Maybe the stunning kitchen bathed in natural light? The designer has melded modern touches with the home's original historic accents giving every square inch charm and character. The main living room boasts breathtaking hardwood floors and a gorgeous spread of windows. The jaw-dropping kitchen showcases navy upper cabinets and wooden lowers with a center island where you'll look forward to gathering with your people. The pantry cabinets are plentiful and —bonus—there's a coffee bar to boot! On your way to the quaint dining room, be sure to notice the original buffet for extra storage and display. The dining room includes a spacious closet for extra storage. Just off your dining area is a laundry room. From here, you''ll see your door to your fenced in back yard that's just waiting for you to set up your grill. Also from the dining area, you're steps away from a large room that can be used as a home office, music room, artist studio, homeschool room or bedroom. This room has its own access to the garage, outside through another door and a quaint side porch. Tons of natural light and attractive accent fireplace. Primary bedroom features another accent fireplace (that was the original coal burning one). This bedroom offers an en suite full bathroom with designer features including a floating vanity. From your bathroom, enter your roomy walk-in closet. There's a second huge downstairs bedroom with outdoor access and easy access to a full bathroom that is a perfect marriage between modern and historic. Just super cool! Head upstairs to your private oasis. There's a nook at the top of the stairs perfect for a comfortable chair for morning coffee, sitting and reading or writing at your desk. Unique and beautiful full bathroom also upstairs. The SECOND PRIMARY bedroom is huge and its shape cozies up the space. You'll love the brand new premium carpet and portola paint + THREE walk-in closets upstairs! (There is a chest that belong to the original owners. It's still a mystery as to how it got up here, but it's not coming down unless we take it apart. Think of this "treasure chest" as an accent table and keep it OR we can take it apart and away!) The unfinished basement offering plenty of storage. Two-car garage in this neighborhood is hard to come by, but this address has it! New Roof!! Two porches, one including a porch swing where you can sway and celebrate that you've found this special home! 601 Brown Ave is loaded with innovative warmth and ready to welcome you!

601 Brown Ave, Shelbyville

4 Beds 3 Baths 1653468 MLS
STYLISH, OPEN DESIGN...UPSCALED, ELEGANT TOUCHES...CONVENIENT, SOUGHT-AFTER LOCATION...This 4 Bedroom, 3 Bath All Brick Ranch Home with Finished Basement has that and much more! From Luxurious Landscaping to a Large, Private Backyard to a Spacious Interior and Exterior, Excellence and Care are evidenced throughout. Enter along a Well Manicured, Picturesque Lawn via a Covered Front Porch into a Spacious, Beautiful Foyer, Flanked by the Dining Room on one side, featuring a Vaulted Ceiling, Wainscoting, and a Palladium Window, and Opening into the Magnificent Great Room. The Great Room is Accented by Crown Moulding, Beautiful Laminate Wood Flooring, Double-Trey Ceiling and a Brick Wood-Burning Fireplace. The Mantle above is Extraordinarya wooden beam about 100 years old removed from a barn in Kentucky. The Family Dining Room, Encased by Windows, connects to the Large Kitchen, Featuring an Island for Extra Seating, New Upscaled White Cabinetry, New Quartz Countertops, Beautiful Tile Backsplash, New Farm-Style Double Sink, SS Appliances, and a Cabinet Pantry. The Laundry is Tiled, has a Utility Sink, and Cabinets above. The Primary En Suite is perfectly Appointed and includes a Huge Bedroom, Bay Windows with a Door Leading to the Deck, 2 Closets (One has Built-Ins for Shoes, and the Other is a Walk-Through Closet Complete with a Built-In Drawer System.) The Bath has Double Sinks, Tiled Flooring, Floating Shelves, and an Extended Walk-In Double Shower with Rain Shower and Hand Wand, as well as a Built-in Seat, and Highlighted by Gorgeous Floor-to-Ceiling Tile. Two Additional Bedrooms with Newer Ceiling Fans and Large Closets (one is Walk-In), and a Completely Updated Hall Bath with a Custom Tub, Tile, and a Rain Shower System, Complete the Main Level. The Spacious Lower Level has recently been Finished and Features a Sound System, a Large Family Room, a Game/Exercise Room, a Fourth Bedroom with Walk-In Closet, and Another Full Bath. Also located on this level is the Massive 2 1/2 Car Garage. The Focus of the Exterior is the Extensive Newer Deck and the Private, Tree-Lined Backyard, both Creating a Perfect Spot to Entertain. Lots of Windows and Natural Light, Open Spaces, Newer Touches Throughout including Closet Systems, and a Brand New Water Heater, Tile and Laminate Wood Flooring, Storage and Closets Galore are just some of the Amenities of this Fabulous Home. It truly is Move-In Ready! Call for your Private Showing, and PACK YOUR BAGS!

3701 Charleston Way, Shelbyville

4 Beds 3 Baths 1589949 MLS
They always say Realtors have the best homes. There has never been a home description more difficult for me to write. This home might be the best example of ''pride of ownership, EVER.'' It has been loved by my family for almost a decade. We have done everything to it. The neighbors joked about what project we could possibly be doing now. We did our absolute best to keep all the character and charm this home has to offer in tact, while giving it all the updates that worked for our family. We added an additional 11 windows and a full dormer to this 4 bedroom 2.5 bathroom home. We removed all the vinyl siding (hard to believe someone covered up the original wood siding) restored the original wood siding and replaced what needed to be replaced. We added a driveway and parking pad. We ran all the utilities underground while doing it. Its the only home in the area with underground power lines. The kitchen was the last of the huge projects and it was completed in 2018. Full tear down to the studs. Spray foam was used in the walls and ceiling and even under the flooring in the butlers pantry area. Custom cabinets hand build by Chino Ross of Countryside cabinets. Quartzite countertops, top of the line appliances and flooring brought in from an old home in Tennessee to match the rest of the home as best as possible. All the plumbing in this home has been replaced, including the sewer main all the way to Brown ave. All the electrical has been replace, even upgrading service to 400 amp. Garage is on its own meter (also underground power lines) and has a hook up for a 50amp RV plug pin the driveway. The roof (which has a lifetime shingle and copper drip edge), all 3 HVAC's porch roofs, garage doors, garage door openers have all been replaced in the last few years. Some of these items were replace in 2020 and 2021. All the floors have been stripped and refinished. All paint removed for all the interior doors and door hardware, all paint from steps and handrails. Every window has been replaced (except for 1 original window at bottom of the steps) and most are triple pane windows. Entire front porch was rebuilt using as many original pieces as possible, including returning the roof of the porch to pure copper. That is a hand made copper roof, with custom copper box gutters and downspouts. The only way to really appreciate all that has been done to this house is to see it in person. We can only hope that this home will bring you as much happiness and joy as it did for us.

700 Brown Ave, Shelbyville

5 Beds 4 Baths 1589087 MLS
Serenity in the country! Spectacular Farmhouse with over 3400sf of character and charm surrounded by 5 beautiful acres with fenced pasture, out building, run-in shed, additional shed and chicken coop. The huge, magnificent front porch will be your favorite outdoor living space to relax and enjoy a nice breeze! Inside, a beautiful foyer showcases the original staircase that opens into the living and family rooms. The dining and separate breakfast rooms provide an abundance of space. The large kitchen is finished in natural wood plank walls with tin ceiling tiles, wide plank wood flooring and walk-in pantry. High ceilings, French doors and lots of windows provide natural lighting to compliment the many original details of this home. The first floor primary bedroom with en-suite full bath, laundry and kitchen could also make the perfect private suite for family or guests. Up the rear staircase are three large bedrooms, a full bath, huge cedar-lined closet and a beautiful, light-filled sunroom that would make a wonderful office, craft room or sitting room. The basement has lots of storage space, laundry and half bath. The outdoor acreage features endless opportunities for your personal hobbies & interests. Updates in 2020 include New Roof, Full Exterior Paint and New 6" Gutters. New Septic System 2018, New Hybrid H20 Water Heater 2016, New Radon Mitigation System 2015. Termite inspection in 2020 with Warranty through Terminex. Great schools and only 20 minutes from I-64 exit (off I-265) and 9 miles from the county line. You will want to see this house and all it has to offer!

1729 Finchville Rd, Shelbyville

4 Beds 3 Baths 1587076 MLS
Welcome to 2105 Benson Pike. Enjoy this country living while only 2 minutes from Shelbyville. This is your own 5 Acres of a peaceful piece of paradise. This brick & stone ranch is so inviting and a great place to call home! This home offers 3-4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths. Walking into a beautiful Foyer you can see through to the green, lush, private backyard. 9 ft ceilings throughout make this home feel spacious & bright. Large Great Room has built-in bookshelves, gas fireplace and hardwood floors. Formal Dining Rm, separate eating area. The Kitchen layout makes for easy work space and has 2 built-in pantries equipped with pull-out shelving. Granite center island and hardwood floors. Huge laundry room with more pantry shelving and cabinets. Primary Bedroom is on one side and the other 3 bedrooms (one of which doesn't have a closet makes a nice guest room/office). The primary closet space is a fabulous surprise (a must see). The sunroom overlooking the back of the property & partial pond is a great place to have coffee in the morning, read or unwind in the evening. 2.5 car garage just has a couple of steps down from the Kitchen. Plus a great hobby room to work on crafts or extra storage. A few of the sellers improvements include: light fixtures replaced inside & outside, recessed lighting, Quartz counter top, tile back-splash, new sink, faucet & cabinet hardware, new stainless range & dishwasher. New hardwood flooring in Primary Bedroom and barn door. Bedrooms have new carpet. Plumbing run to the Detached building with concrete floors, bath, and office. New shutters, landscaping, Gilkey replacement windows on patio with new door, newly painted interior. You need to see this to appreciate the feeling this home brings!

2105 Benson Pike, Shelbyville

3 Beds 4 Baths 1586793 MLS
526 CREEK SIDE DRIVE OFFERS SOME INCREDIBLE AMAZING PARK LIKE VIEWS ON 2.0 ACRES WITH LOTS OF BEAUTIFUL TREES, GARDENS, FLOWERING PLANTS, AND A BABBLING CREEK! This IMPRESSIVE BRICK RANCH has 3 Bedrooms, 3 Full Baths and 1 Half Bath, with a partially finished walk out basement, and two gas fireplaces is SUPER CLEAN and ready for you! THERE ARE MANY UPGRADES THAT NEED TO BE MENTIONED: SELLER HAD A very energy efficient TRANE 20 seer HVAC System with the Trane CleanEffects whole-house air filtration system and humidifier installed approximately 3 years ago, CHECK OUT THE LOW UTILITIES! ROOF WAS REPLACED IN 2017!! THE SELLER INSTALLED HARDWOOD FLOORS IN ALL THREE OF THE BEDROOMS and closets! The Eat-In Kitchen comes complete with complimentary appliances. In 2020 the kitchen refrigerator, wall oven, dishwasher and microwave were just purchased! The Spacious eat-in kitchen opens to the Great Room. The Primary Bedroom is located on the first floor, and offers a very spacious suite complete with a balcony, walk in closet and Primary Bathroom. The lower level offers lots of finished space with a Family Room, room for a Game Area, wet bar and gas fireplace. The basement also contains a third full bathroom, second laundry room, and plenty of storage in the unfinished area. NICE THINGS TO KNOW: 3 BAY GARAGE (MAIN FLOOR) & THE LOWER LEVEL HAS A SERVICE GARAGE, there are two laundry rooms available, one on the first floor, and another laundry room is located in the lower level. THERE IS NO HOA!!! The covered deck even is plumbed for gas if you have a grill! Lower level patio happens to be wired for a hot tub! THERE IS AN UNDERGROUND FENCE, (dog collars do not remain). SCHEDULE AN APPOINTMENT TODAY!

526 Creek Side Dr, Shelbyville

4 Beds 4 Baths 1583108 MLS
This stunning 4 Bedroom, 4 Full Bath home in Magnolia Place is a must see to believe with lots of special features, upgrades and fabulous layout. The main level boasts of hardwood floors in the Great Room, Kitchen, Hall & Bath. The Great Room has a custom feature wall of 100 year old ceiling tiles hand-painted by award winning artist, Rhonda McEnroe and has ventless gas log fireplace. The Great Room is open to the dining area then to Kitchen. It also opens to the deck areas and has peaceful view of park space & creek. Recent upgrades for the Kitchen include granite counter tops, copper sink, faucet and new stainless appliances (2020). The large Master Suite has a tray ceiling, the Master Bath has new granite & Moen fixtures. The split bedroom plan offers privacy with 2 other bedrooms and hall bath on the main level. For convenience the laundry room is on the main level as well. Upstairs is a very roomy 4th bedroom and full bath. Plus lots of attic storage. The lower level is finished with a family room, "other" room and full bath plus huge storage closet that looks like a great place to hide Christmas presents. Outside is a wealth of beauty and potential relaxation. The double deck invites lounging while looking over nature. This backyard backs up to park area and walking track. There's lots of beautiful plantings and custom rock-scaping with a rock wall under the deck & tree line. There are too many upgrades to mention, there's a separate list in the disclosure.

115 Blossom Cir, Shelbyville

5 Beds 4 Baths 1578221 MLS
Welcome to 518 Foxwood Court. This gorgeous 5BR home has been extensively remodeled and has a fantastic floorplan made for spacious and comfortable family living. Working from home or NTI? Check out the large room over the garage, huge closet and lots of storage space. CoreTec Lifetime flooring throughout and Shaw carpeting in the upstairs. Kitchen boasts GE appliances, a gas range with stainless hood vent surrounded by herringbone tile, farmhouse sink and custom painted island, new granite throughout. The main level, primary bedroom will win your heart with it's trey ceilings, large walk in closet with room for a custom makeup vanity and multiple windows overlooking your expansive backyard. Let the Master Bath wow you with it's gorgeous custom tile shower, freestanding so soaker tub and custom vanity. Plus, a toilet closet and linen closet! The formal dining room has wainscotting and a large window as well as custom LED lighting for those special occassions. The great room boasts vaulted ceilings and a gorgeous fireplace with shiplap, a custom made mantle and cabinetry. Freshly painted, gorgeous and welcoming front door, all new fixtures throughout. Walk out basement with rough in plumbing and ready to be finished to your liking. 2 New HVAC units, large laundry, 2 car garage and step out onto the newly updated, huge deck overlooking your spacious backyard that is ready for your touches. This home is move in ready and completely updated for you. Schedule your showing today!

518 Foxwood Ct, Shelbyville

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Shelbyville Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Shelbyville and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!