Shelbyville KY MLS Search

View All Latest Shelbyville 2500+ Sq. Ft. Properties for Sale

$369,900
4 Beds 4 Baths 1658995 MLS
This home is so much bigger than it looks! This exceptional home is perfectly located with easy access to Interstate 64, offering over 3,000 sqft of meticulously designed living space that harmonizes style and functionality effortlessly. As you step onto the main floor you will immediately noticed the recently refinished hardwood floors! The expansive great room seamlessly flows into the open-concept kitchen, perfect for hosting gatherings or enjoying everyday living. Recently replaced custom cabinets (including new pantry) and newly added granite countertops, along with updated appliances including the refrigerator and dishwasher, enhance the kitchen's appeal. For formal occasions, the dining room adds a touch of refinement. On the main level, the generously sized primary suite features a walk-in closet, while a large laundry room and powder room add convenience. Upstairs, three more bedrooms and another full bathroom offer plenty of space for family or guests. The fully finished basement boasts a large family or recreational room, another large room perfect for at home office or gym(currently used as a bedroom) complemented by newly installed stylish luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring. In addition, recent upgrades such as the SECOND-FLOOR HVAC system and a replaced roof ensure comfort, durability, and peace of mind. This is likely one of the only homes in the neighborhood that has had a second floor HVAC system added to the home. Don't let this opportunity pass you byschedule a visit to experience the charm and practicality of this exceptional property firsthand!

304 Pierremont Dr, Shelbyville

$469,900
3 Beds 4 Baths 1658888 MLS
She's an absolute beauty! This jaw-dropper of a home on historic Magnolia Avenue is the perfect mix of historic details and modern touches! Nearly every inch of this home was renovated approximately 2 years ago! You'll find tons of gorgeous personal living space, loads of room for entertaining on the inside, a fire pit out back to gather with friends, plus a 2-bay detached garage with a second floor that could be used for anything your mind might dream up from extra storage to a craft room to a place to have band practice. The possibilities are endless! Speaking of possibilities, there are a few options to explore at 709 Magnolia Ave: Option 1- Make it your personal home! It's the kind of home that makes the front of a Hallmark card, one that just welcomes you to cozy up and stay a while. This street is the kind of place where you can see neighbors taking after-dinner strolls, walking their dogs, or learning to ride bikes. You're tucked in close to downtown and near great restaurants and shops plus just a few minutes from the bypass and interstate. It's the kind of place that just feels like home. Option 2: The current owners use the house for short-term rental and have had slam dunk success on Airbnb. Pick this up as part of your short-term rental portfolio or confidently enter the Airbnb world with a property with a proven track record. Complete furniture package negotiable. Either way -- home sweet home or Airbnb, don't miss the chance to see 709 Magnolia Ave. Join me Monday night from 5pm-7pm for an evening Open House or schedule your private showing.

709 Magnolia Ave, Shelbyville

$549,900
4 Beds 5 Baths 1657848 MLS
Your DREAM HOME awaits....Sitting on 1.2 acres in the much desired neighborhood of Weissinger Estates. This unicorn features it all! It's two, two, two homes in one. That's right you have a gorgeous custom ranch home all on one level and then a totally finished walkout basement that has everything needed for another complete home. On the main level you will immediately feel at home when you are greeted with a view of the great room with fireplace. Welcome your guests in your cozy living room/sitting area directly off entry. Stunning dining room is sure to host many memorable dinners with family and friends. Your primary bedroom and en suite primary bath is tucked away on it's own private section of the home. Ready to be ''wow'ed?'' Check out the TWO walk-in closets in primary an the custom double vanity arrangement. Not that laundry is ever fun....but with the spacious laundry room on main level you won't mind it nearly as much. Kitchen has beautiful white cabinetry and a breakfast room adjoining it. Now to the other side of the house where you will find two bedrooms with a jack and jill bathroom. Throughout the home seller has updated fixtures and fans. The amazing screened in florida room is directly off breakfast room so you can enjoy coffee/tea/wine at every hour of the day. You will be looking out over the expansive yard that has been professionally treated on a regular basis and is fully fenced for privacy. Sellers added landscaping that will please everyone and a cozy fire pit. Added to landscaping was a handsome magnolia tree, 4 zelkovas and 4 maples. Oversized deck will accommodate more seating for your enjoyment and has been built with extra storage below deck. Ready for living area number TWO? Nice open den greets you downstairs. And let's not forget the incredible amount of storage in this home. Wait till you see all the closets and open storage rooms. Two full baths in lower level along with a FULL kitchen basically never used and wonderful appliances and cabinets. Also a room currently used as an office that could be used for many other room options. Added bonus features....new roof, new soffits, new water heater, 4 new storm doors, fresh paint in kitchen and more. Words alone cannot describe all the features this property hosts. Must see to appreciate. Schedule now to be the first to see!

70 Weissinger Ct, Shelbyville

$925,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 1657099 MLS
This is one of a kind in Shelby County! Lovely setting on 5.6 lush acres with scattered trees with fencing and beautiful views. All conveniently located close to downtown Shelbyville with easy access to By-pass and I-64. Built in the early 1950's, this home defines a solid, quality home. The builder lived there and built it for himself and family (Previously owner of Long Block Co. In Shelbyville). Bedford stone, concrete and plaster walls and metal roof. Situated on the rear of the property makes it very private. You are welcomed by a sprawling front porch and awesome Foyer. Stepping down in to the formal Living Room with beautiful windows and fireplace looking out over the front of the property. Formal Dining Room, large Kitchen and separate breakfast eating area. Family Room with gas fireplace in the back of the house is cozy and comfortable. This can be opened up to the rear sunporch. 2 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms with laundry room complete the main level. 3 more spacious bedrooms upstairs with 2 full baths. The closet space and built-in bookshelves and cabinets are beautiful. This home has an abundance of storage space. All on an unfinished full basement with walk-up access and 2nd laundry. Outside you will also have an English Garden and over 30 kinds of daylilies. Several family weddings have been lucky enough to have this gorgeous backyard. Also an older log home with stone fireplace was moved to the property and formally used as a wood working shop. A barn/equipment shed are also located on the property. Collected rain water around the house is used for outside spigots connected to house. Also 2 separate watering pumps are connected to city water in the back yard area. Fiber optics have been completed. This is truly a beautiful and comfortable home. Lots of new family gatherings and celebrations will be planned for this home!

302 Eminence Pike, Shelbyville

$510,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 1656755 MLS
Welcome to this charming ranch home nestled on 4 acres of picturesque land. This spacious property boasts a barn, a small shed, and the tranquility of a shared pond, offering a perfect blend of rural serenity and modern convenience. Upon entering from the welcoming front porch, you are greeted by a cozy dining room that seamlessly flows into the inviting living room, complete with a comforting fireplace and a bay window. The well-appointed kitchen features an island, ample counterspace, and cabinets, catering to culinary enthusiasts. The large family room with vaulted ceilings floods the space with natural light, creating an airy and inviting atmosphere. Connected to the family room are an office and a spacious laundry room, adding to the functionality of the home. Retreat to the primary bedroom, which boasts a generous size, a walk-in closet, and an en-suite bath featuring a double vanity, a shower, and a luxurious soaking tub. Two additional bedrooms share a full bathroom. The fourth bedroom, a second primary bedroom, enjoys the convenience of an attached full bath. The basement offers versatility with a large finished bonus room and two spacious unfinished areas, providing ample storage or potential for customization. The lower entry 3-car garage adds to the practicality of the home. Outside, the backyard features a deck and a patio, perfect for outdoor entertaining or simply enjoying the peaceful views of the expansive land. Whether you're seeking tranquility or space to roam, this ranch home offers a harmonious blend of comfort and natural beauty.

5228 Orphan Ln, Shelbyville

$?
3 Beds 5 Baths 1655653 MLS
RARE FIND & READY FOR NEW OWNERS! FIRST TIME ON THE MARKET, THIS METICULOUSLY CARED FOR HOME IS A MUST SEE! Sitting on a gorgeously manicured 5.68 acre tract on Aiken Rd, you will have a PRIME LOCATION just minutes from Shelbyville, Simpsonville, Jefferson County, Henry County or Oldham County. Driving up to the home on the tree lined, custom, concrete driveway you will notice the beauty & stewardship of this property. You are greeted with manicured landscaping, a lush yard, & beautiful views of this highly sought after area of Shelby County. Enter the home through the new Pine wood front door & step into the vaulted foyer of this open floor plan home with beautiful wood floors. The dining room is spacious with tray ceiling & crown molding details. The Great Room is vast with a vaulted ceiling ,loads of natural light, & a GRAND dual sided stone fireplace that is wood burning with propane igniters & adjoins the kitchen eating area, giving both spaces the luxury of this fireplace. The large eat-in kitchen has Corian counters, great cabinet space, island work area, & a walk-in pantry. Enjoy gorgeous view of the property from here for your meals or step right out onto the large deck that is great for outdoor entertaining. Past the Great Room you will enter the Primary Suite with another beautiful wood burning stone fireplace & access to the screened-in porch sitting area. The ensuite has custom tile work with a large glass enclosed shower, double vanities, & enormous walk-in closet room. The ensuite also has plenty of room for a makeup vanity space & custom plantation blinds for privacy. Also on the main level is a half bath & a large laundry room with sink, cabinets, & counterspace. With a 4 car garage off of the kitchen, this home has a floor plan that flows easily & is spacious. Upstairs there are 2 bedrooms with their own personal full bathrooms & walk in closets. There is also a walk-in attic with great storage space. The finished walk-out basement is open with a wood burning fireplace, family room, gaming area, & bar area. There is a full bath with custom tile work, a large utility space with epoxy flooring, & great storage space. Additionally there is another 2 car garage on this level with a retractable screen door. From the basement step out onto a large patio space with a pergola, fenced in courtyard with stonework pillars, landscape lighting, & a gorgeous creek stone water feature with a waterfall & immaculate landscaping. Enjoy relaxing by the enchanting stream or listening to it from up above it in the screened-in porch on the deck overlooking the beautiful gently rolling property with a tree line at the back for privacy. This home has so many upgraded features including a NEW roof with transferable lifetime warranty, NEW gutters, NEW Andersen windows, smart lighting system, solid pine interior doors, central vac, security system, Wirsbo Pex water lines, flood censors to shut water off, & many other great details listed on a features sheet that agent can provide. DON'T MISS THIS RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN THIS INCREDIBLE HOME IN A PERFECT LOCATION!

626 Aiken Rd, Shelbyville

$?
4 Beds 3 Baths 1654651 MLS
It doesn't get much better than this!! 4 BEDROOM +3 FULL bathrooms on a CORNER LOT on sought-after Brown Avenue! It's hard to know where your eyes should land first! The stand out finishes? The moody, rich paint colors? Maybe the stunning kitchen bathed in natural light? The designer has melded modern touches with the home's original historic accents giving every square inch charm and character. The main living room boasts breathtaking hardwood floors and a gorgeous spread of windows. The jaw-dropping kitchen showcases navy upper cabinets and wooden lowers with a center island where you'll look forward to gathering with your people. The pantry cabinets are plentiful and —bonus—there's a coffee bar to boot! On your way to the quaint dining room, be sure to notice the original buffet for extra storage and display. The dining room includes a spacious closet for extra storage. Just off your dining area is a laundry room. From here, you''ll see your door to your fenced in back yard that's just waiting for you to set up your grill. Also from the dining area, you're steps away from a large room that can be used as a home office, music room, artist studio, homeschool room or bedroom. This room has its own access to the garage, outside through another door and a quaint side porch. Tons of natural light and attractive accent fireplace. Primary bedroom features another accent fireplace (that was the original coal burning one). This bedroom offers an en suite full bathroom with designer features including a floating vanity. From your bathroom, enter your roomy walk-in closet. There's a second huge downstairs bedroom with outdoor access and easy access to a full bathroom that is a perfect marriage between modern and historic. Just super cool! Head upstairs to your private oasis. There's a nook at the top of the stairs perfect for a comfortable chair for morning coffee, sitting and reading or writing at your desk. Unique and beautiful full bathroom also upstairs. The SECOND PRIMARY bedroom is huge and its shape cozies up the space. You'll love the brand new premium carpet and portola paint + THREE walk-in closets upstairs! (There is a chest that belong to the original owners. It's still a mystery as to how it got up here, but it's not coming down unless we take it apart. Think of this "treasure chest" as an accent table and keep it OR we can take it apart and away!) The unfinished basement offering plenty of storage. Two-car garage in this neighborhood is hard to come by, but this address has it! New Roof!! Two porches, one including a porch swing where you can sway and celebrate that you've found this special home! 601 Brown Ave is loaded with innovative warmth and ready to welcome you!

601 Brown Ave, Shelbyville

$?
3 Beds 2 Baths 1654333 MLS
Prime location Alert! Ranch retreat on 6.51 Acres! Seamless blend of country charm and city convenience with this stunning ranch-style home. Boasting a generous 2,088 sqft of main level living space, complemented by an additional 907 sqft finished walk-out basement, this residence is turn key. As you open the front door and step inside the dedicated foyer you will begin to see immediately the appeal of this home highlighted by the open floor plan. Owners ensured plenty of natural light and amazing views with thoughtfully place windows throughout the home. Not a single square foot wasted. The home's design ensures every room flows effortlessly into the next, highlighted by the luxurious 5'' artisan handcrafted engineered hardwood flooring. The open kitchen features granite countertops, large kitchen island, gorgeous custom cabinetry, and open shelving that flanks the stainless steel oven. The split floor plan offers unparalleled privacy for the primary suite, featuring a walk-in tiled shower that promises a spa-like retreat every day. The additional bedrooms ensure comfort and space for family and guests alike. Venture to the walk out basement and discover a versatile space that caters to your every need, with smart core luxury vinyl plank flooring that is both 100% water and pet-proof, ensuring durability and ease. Worth noting, Owners invested in steel beams so that the basement could be more open. There is ample space to have a fourth bedroom and is pre-plumbed for an additional bathroom. Outside, the magic of this property continues. The large attached garage provides plenty of room for vehicles and hobbies. The 24'x24' barn stands ready for your farming/gardening/storage needs. The location is perfect for those who appreciate the quiet peace of the countryside while still being close to the city's amenities (Less than 5 minutes to Kroger and just 6 miles to I-64). Set up your private showing today!

251 Clear Creek Rd, Shelbyville

$399,900
4 Beds 4 Baths 1654159 MLS
First Time on The Market! Indulge in luxury living in this custom built four bedroom three and a half bathroom with finish walkout basement two story home at just under $400,000. Welcome your guests into your foyer with beautiful wainscoting and crown molding. Entertaining them will be easy with the open floor plan, built-in bar in the basement, and two-tier deck in the backyard that is hardwired for internet and equipped with a tv mount, you just need to supply your own tv. Granite countertops, island with storage and seating, buffet server, Aristokraft cabinetry, butler pantry, and stainless-steel appliances make the kitchen a room you'll enjoy spending so much time in. The mudroom with built in shelving and scratch proof flooring throughout the first floor makes everyday living a little simpler. The insulated extended 2 car attached garage will keep your extra-long bed trucks out of the heat in the summer and cold in the winter. Working from home is simple with a first-floor home office. No need to drag your laundry to the basement as the second floor is equipped with a laundry area, a loft area currently being used as a second-floor family room, a full bath in the hallway, three nice size bedrooms, and the primary bedroom with a walk-in closet, transom windows, and tray ceilings. The primary bathroom has a counter height vanity with his and her sinks, an extra-large garden tub and separate shower. The fenced in backyard can be accessed through the first-floor sliding patio door or the walkout finished basement. and you'll find there is a community pool and playground area for your enjoyment. Rod iron railing, 10-foot ceilings, two large storage closets and a full bathroom with a tiled shower in the basement community pool and playground round off the many custom upgrades you get with this beautiful home. Owner will be leaving the security system.

6040 Edgemont Way, Shelbyville

$?
4 Beds 3 Baths 1653468 MLS
STYLISH, OPEN DESIGN...UPSCALED, ELEGANT TOUCHES...CONVENIENT, SOUGHT-AFTER LOCATION...This 4 Bedroom, 3 Bath All Brick Ranch Home with Finished Basement has that and much more! From Luxurious Landscaping to a Large, Private Backyard to a Spacious Interior and Exterior, Excellence and Care are evidenced throughout. Enter along a Well Manicured, Picturesque Lawn via a Covered Front Porch into a Spacious, Beautiful Foyer, Flanked by the Dining Room on one side, featuring a Vaulted Ceiling, Wainscoting, and a Palladium Window, and Opening into the Magnificent Great Room. The Great Room is Accented by Crown Moulding, Beautiful Laminate Wood Flooring, Double-Trey Ceiling and a Brick Wood-Burning Fireplace. The Mantle above is Extraordinarya wooden beam about 100 years old removed from a barn in Kentucky. The Family Dining Room, Encased by Windows, connects to the Large Kitchen, Featuring an Island for Extra Seating, New Upscaled White Cabinetry, New Quartz Countertops, Beautiful Tile Backsplash, New Farm-Style Double Sink, SS Appliances, and a Cabinet Pantry. The Laundry is Tiled, has a Utility Sink, and Cabinets above. The Primary En Suite is perfectly Appointed and includes a Huge Bedroom, Bay Windows with a Door Leading to the Deck, 2 Closets (One has Built-Ins for Shoes, and the Other is a Walk-Through Closet Complete with a Built-In Drawer System.) The Bath has Double Sinks, Tiled Flooring, Floating Shelves, and an Extended Walk-In Double Shower with Rain Shower and Hand Wand, as well as a Built-in Seat, and Highlighted by Gorgeous Floor-to-Ceiling Tile. Two Additional Bedrooms with Newer Ceiling Fans and Large Closets (one is Walk-In), and a Completely Updated Hall Bath with a Custom Tub, Tile, and a Rain Shower System, Complete the Main Level. The Spacious Lower Level has recently been Finished and Features a Sound System, a Large Family Room, a Game/Exercise Room, a Fourth Bedroom with Walk-In Closet, and Another Full Bath. Also located on this level is the Massive 2 1/2 Car Garage. The Focus of the Exterior is the Extensive Newer Deck and the Private, Tree-Lined Backyard, both Creating a Perfect Spot to Entertain. Lots of Windows and Natural Light, Open Spaces, Newer Touches Throughout including Closet Systems, and a Brand New Water Heater, Tile and Laminate Wood Flooring, Storage and Closets Galore are just some of the Amenities of this Fabulous Home. It truly is Move-In Ready! Call for your Private Showing, and PACK YOUR BAGS!

3701 Charleston Way, Shelbyville

$?
4 Beds 3 Baths 1650561 MLS
Don't miss a rare opportunity to own this beautifully updated home situated in gorgeous horse farm country in one of the most sought after locations in Shelby County. This 4 bedroom 3 bath ranch home sits on just over 5 acres of flat land and offers a maintenance free exterior. The massive 60x40, 2,400 square foot outbuilding/garage is a mechanic's dream offering a concrete floor, insulation, gas heat, half bath, oil changing pit, lift, workshop, loft, two oversized 14x12 and 12x12 motorized garage doors allow you to drive through instead of having to back out. The building could easily be converted into a horse barn if desired. The workshop would make a great tack room. The highly efficient GEOTHERMAL HVAC system affordably heats and cools the home keeping more of your hard earned dollars in your pocket each and every month. The home boasts nearly 3,000 square feet of finished space. Large 25x12 kitchen offers quartz countertops, marble backsplash, white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, breakfast bar, eat in area and a HUGE walk in pantry. All 4 bedrooms are on the main level. The large and private primary suite offers a walk-in closet. Primary bath comes equipped with an oversized jetted tub, extra storage cabinetry and a walk-in shower. Large family room with a gas log fireplace and built-ins with access to a BIG recently added outdoor patio and a fully fenced in yard. EXTRA LARGE formal dining room will accommodate a table for 8+, buffet and china cabinet. 3 good sized additional bedrooms with large closets, a full bath and laundry room round out the main level. Lower level has a large room that could be an additional living quarters, play room, office, family room or game room. The rest of the lower level offers a full bath including a walk in shower and plenty of extra room for storage. Recent updates include new siding, soffit, fascia, gutters, downspouts, high efficiency insulated windows, freshly painted interior, quartz counters, marble mosaic backsplash, storm doors, side and rear exterior doors, breakfast bar in the kitchen, Kraus contemporary sink with sliding cutting board and faucet, LED dimmable light fixtures, ceiling fans, a 400 gallon propane tank, a 10,000 pound heavy duty lift in the outbuilding and LED dimmable exterior soffit lighting. Dimensional shingle roof is only 12 years old. Oversized 2.5 car attached garage with wall mounted cabinets and plenty of extra room for additional storage. Side entrance ramp provides easy accessibility. Covered front porch. Outbuilding has its own electrical service. Two septic tanks. One for the home and a separate tank for the outbuilding bathroom. Two water heater tanks provide lots of hot water. Close to everything in Shelbyville. Just 3 minutes to the elementary, middle and high schools as well as the ball fields and shopping. Only 5 minutes to Guest Creek. This property has a registered farm designation which could potentially qualify you for tax breaks.

393 Cranbourne Grange, Shelbyville

$?
5 Beds 4 Baths 1596598 MLS
Check out this gorgeous custom brick home situated on 6.91 acres of land in the beautiful countryside of Shelbyville, KY! Located just 10 minutes from I-64, 15 minutes from I-71, and 15 minutes from the Outlet Shoppes of the Bluegrass in Simpsonville. The long treelined driveway leading to this stately home is breathtaking. The home features exterior french doors and natural hardwood floors. There is an open dining room great room space that features high ceilings, crown molding, crisp white pillars, a stone wood burning fireplace attached to built-in cabinets, and lots of natural sunlight peering through the large windows. The kitchen features a double gas stove, double ovens, tile backsplash, pendant lighting, and a center granite-topped sink island/bar area that seats 3-4, and a large pantry with plenty of shelving. There is a double-door entrance to the outside deck off the breakfast area in the kitchen. There is also a beautiful sunroom located with tons of natural lighting located off of the kitchen area. Spacious mudroom, half bathroom, and office also located on the first floor.The primary bedroom has trey ceilings and an entrance door to the back deck. The large en-suite primary bathroom features his and hers tile showers, as well as separate sinks and vanities, there is a separate water room closet. Adjoining the en-suite are 2 large walk-in closets with ample shelving. The laundry room features a sink, tile floor, shelves, and cabinets for Two additional bedrooms that share a Jack and Jill style full bathroom with double sinks.The basement features both carpet and wood flooring, stone archways, a large family room, a living room, and an eating area. Off of the living room, there is also a small sitting area. The kitchenette/bar area has plenty of space with custom Amish cabinetry, and an island with pendant lighting and bar seating. There is a door off of the living room that leads to the backyard and patio. Additional sleeping areas with two large bedrooms and a full bathroom in the hallway. The unfinished area is over 1000 sqft and has a partially finished workout area. The land is mostly flat and has a gentle rolling hill close to the house. This is a property beautiful property with stunning views and extra privacy.

4601 Lagrange Rd, Shelbyville

Start Your Search

2500+ Sq. Ft. Shelbyville Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for 2500+ sq. ft. properties available in Shelbyville and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!